Inbrief: Free Legal Information

 

Home   About   Advertising  Contributors 

 
   

Search In Brief

Over a thousand pages of free legal information written by our selected team of legal experts

 
 

Browse Legal Topics

Ask a Solicitor Online

   

Intellectual Property

General

Intellectual Property Rights

Illegally Downloading Music

Open Source Software Licences

Passing Off

Claiming Royalties Art Work

Self Publishing Versus Publishing House

Copyright

Copyright

Copyright The Basics

Copyright Infringement

Remedies for Copyright Infringement

Who can Claim Copyright Infringement?

Criminal Liability for Copyright Infringement

Copyright Tribunals

Can Ideas be Protected by Copyright?

What are Moral Rights?

How long does Copyright last?

Copyright and Websites

Copyright for Freelance Writers

Copyright in Literary, Dramatic and Musical Works

Copyright in Artistic Works

Copyright in Sound Recordings and Films

Copyright in Broadcasts

Copyright in Published editions

Copyright Licensing Agency

Computer Generated Works Copyright

Copyright Protection for Software

Copyright Technological Protection Measures

Internet Service Providers Copyright Illegal Material

Defence of Fair Dealing in Copyright Law

Trademarks

Trade Marks

How to apply for a Trade Mark

Renewing a Trade Mark

Refusal of Trade Mark

Trademark Infringement

Trade Marks Relative Grounds for Refusal

Defences to Trademark Infringement

Unregistered Trade Marks

Registration of Food Names

Patents

Patents

How to apply for a Patent

Renewing a Patent

Patent Infringement

Defences to Patent Infringement

Confidentiality

Information Commissioner Data Protection Act Powers

Protection of Company Information

Data Protection Requirements for Business

Design Rights

How to register a Design

Renewing a registered Design

Unregistered Design Right

Semiconductor Design Rights

What acts will constitute infringement of a registered trademark?

The first thing to note when dealing with the potential infringement of a trademark is to ensure that the trademark has in fact been registered.

If this is the case then the trademark will be an official registered trademark which will confer various rights on the owner of the mark. One of the rights conferred to the owner of a trademark under the Trade Marks Act 1994 is the right to prevent unauthorised use of that trade mark by third parties in respect to the goods or services specified on the register.

Furthermore the European Union law Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights states that the owner of a registered trade mark has the exclusive right to prevent all third parties from using the similar signs for goods or services which are identical or similar to those for which the trademark is registered.

What is meant by unauthorised use?

One of the key elements in order to establish whether the use of something has been authorised to establish whether the owner of the mark has in fact consented to the use of the mark. If there has been no consent the third party will not be authorised to use it.

How is consent given?

As is the case with various other aspects of Intellectual Property Law the owner of a trademark can license or even the sell the authorised use of it to third parties.

Is lack of consent enough to prove infringement?

Unfortunately lack of consent for the use of the trademark is not enough to prove infringement as there are a variety of other factors which need to be present.

Trademark infringement

In order to establish that there has in fact been a trademark infringement the following must be established:

In the course of trade

What is meant by in the course of trade?

When establishing whether the use of a mark has taken place in the course of trade we can look to a decision handed down by the European Court of Justice. The ECJ has stated that for something to be in the course of trade it must take place in the context of a commercial activity which has a view to an economic advantage and not one which is simply a private matter.

Following on from this the use of a trademark by an organisation or an individual whom is not acting in a commercial way will not be seen as being in the course of trade.

In practice if money changes hands or if a company is using a mark to promote their goods whereby they receive income this is likely to be found to be within the course of trade.

The Trade Marks Act 1994

The Trade Marks Act specifies the following acts as infringements to a registered trademark:

Identical marks on identical goods and services

If a third party uses a mark which is identical to a trademark registered by another individual on goods or services which are identical to those which the registered trademark is used for there will be an infringement.

This is often the case when someone may wish to pass of counterfeit clothing as real by using the identical brand logo on an identical item of clothing.

What does it mean for a mark to be identical?

For a mark to be seen as identical it must be reproduced without any modifications made to it.

What happens if the mark has been modified?

If the mark has been modified but these modifications are only seen as minor or insignificant and where they are noticeable from the average consumers perspective then they will still be seen as identical. If the modifications are more than minor then the infringement may fall into the second category specified by the act.

Identical or similar marks for identical or similar goods and services

As is often the case in counterfeit clothing or something similar a third party will use an identical mark on similar goods and services or they will use a similar mark on similar goods and services. This will not automatically result in a trademark infringement however as in order for there to have been an infringement the following must be established:

How is this established?

In order to establish the above criteria the following factors will be taken into account by a court:

Conflict with a mark of repute

This specified infringement is to deal with the scenario where an identical or similar mark is used on goods or services that are not similar to those goods or services which the registered trademark represents.

In order to establish infringement in that case the owner of the registered trademark will have to establish that the registered trademark has a reputation within the UK and either one of the following:

Unfair Advantage

An unfair advantage means that the use of the similar or identical mark is an attempt to associate itself with the registered mark and exploit the goodwill associated with that mark.

Detrimental to the distinctive character

Where the use of another mark is said to be detrimental to the distinctive character of the registered mark it means that the registered mark’s association with certain goods or services is no longer immediately recognised.

Still have unanswered questions?

Ask your legal question using the box below and have a response from solicitor or barrister within minutes.