Requests for further information in civil litigation

Disclosure procedures and requests for further information

The process of disclosure provides for all relevant information to be shared with the other parties to the proceedings prior to the trial. Another means ensuring that all relevant information is disclosed to the other party is the request for further information.

The rules on both procedures require the parties to exchange information they would rely on so that all parties can be prepared for the case they have to meet. Further, embodied in the overriding objective is the need for the matters to be settled justly, quickly and if possible without court interference. Therefore, all disclosure procedures are in the spirit of allowing the parties to attempt and reach an appropriate settlement themselves.

Requesting further information

Requests for further information are made in the effort to explore the causes of action or defences pursued by a party to the proceedings in the first documents exchanged between the parties. They provide an opportunity for the advocates involved in a trial to be very tactical in exploring the information before them. For example they can ask specific questions to expose deficiencies in the other side’s statements of case.

Those requests should generally be made shortly after the relevant statement of case is served. The procedure could also be used to seek clarification of any matter in dispute between the parties even if such has not been mentioned in the relevant statement of case.

The requests and their specifications

Who can make a request?

In principle, a request for further information may be made by any of the parties and court by its own initiative. In practice it is rare for the courts to ask for specific information and whenever they do, it is normally to find out further information for case management including allocation purposes.

The form of the request

Whenever a party is making a request it should be concise and strictly confined to matters which are reasonably necessary and proportionate to enable the party posing the questions to prepare its own case and meet the case against them.

The amount and extent of the disclosure could be limited by the courts. Currently, fishing requests, which are merely testing whether certain information could turn out to be helpful to one side, are disallowed.

Further long and oppressive requests are also not allowed. This is because the procedure is established in light of saving costs and maintaining proportionality in accordance with the overriding objective of the civil proceedings.

Unlock this article now!

 

For more information on:

  • Procedure
  • Objecting to requests